top of page

Crisis Boiling Over: The Risk of Unregulated AI to Canadian Food Security

4 days ago
4 min read

Updated: 2 days ago


In the last eight weeks, large-scale cyberattacks on food supply chains were carried out in at least ten European countries. 

 

Internet-enabled freezers and fridges at major grocery chains were hacked and heated overnight, destroying civilian food supplies in peaceful countries. No-one has yet claimed responsibility or motivation for these attacks, but they were almost certainly enabled by AI, as essentially all cybercrime is these days. 

 

This is not a foreign problem, as most cybercrime is executed internationally, enabled by AI. ‘Black October’ was the worst month in world history for cybersecurity, and more impacts are still coming. Already multiple Canadian grocery stores have seen breaches of their customer data - so the risk of unregulated technology to our supply chain is no longer a hypothetical.

 

It’s long overdue that the Canadian food security sector talk not only about our ongoing crisis of food affordability, but of how unregulated technology around the world could destabilize our food access here at home. 

 

After all - even those of us who can afford food on the table may go home hungry if grocery store shelves are empty, or if prices spike unpredictably based on availability.  

 

So what can be done to protect our food access? 

 

I see two paths forward: 

 

Firstly, Canada must increase local production and diversify our supply chains. 

 

A ‘food sovereignty’ framing is helpful here - food sovereignty concerns itself not just with whether people can access food, but with how much control people have over their own food supply. This framing grew from Indigenous communities the world over, where people still grow and harvest their own food on a village-to-village scale, supplemented by trade, as all our ancestors did until recently. 

 

Industrialized agriculture has increased food production overall, but left people with less community control over whatever food they can access and how it is produced. This trade-off of sovereignty for abundance has felt appropriate to many for much of the last century, but its vulnerabilities are more pressing as the global trade network has been destabilized by war, climate crisis, economic shocks, and cybercrime. 

 

In Canada’s hyperconcentrated food supply chain, four companies control 80% of grocery sales, four companies account for 88% of grain handling capacity, and just two companies dominate meat processing. Large corporations also have increasing control through shell companies and partnership contracts over increasing portions of the supply chain, including transportation.  

 

In contrast, the local farmers who actually produce the food are under-resourced, and massive corporations control not only a majority of the food retail market, but the supply chain that transports and manages our food. 

 

Note: Last year, Mazon used a small portion our total grant budget, which mainly supports direct food aid, to support the National Farmers Union’s research on rising grocery prices, seeking to bring new information to this important national conversation. The results? “Canada’s agri-food oligarchs – the handful of corporations that have power to distort prices and markets – are the primary reason for the widening gap between the farmers’ earnings and the grocery sticker price.” [Read more] 

 

In a system this concentrated,  a significant ransomware attack on just one of our grocery giants could freeze most food deliveries to entire towns - like the 2024 attack on the Toronto Public Library, which froze systems for months, but with much more urgent consequences. 


There’s hope on the horizon for developing our local food infrastructure, though. Canada’s new National Food Security Strategy has faced criticism from the food aid sector, including from Mazon and our national network of partners on this very blog, for failing to adress income as a key driver of food security; the Strategy does almost nothing to alleviate food security for our poorest community members. But when it comes to developing local food infrastructure, it soars. Essentially, the plan focuses on preventing future food insecurity in a destabilized world, rather than supporting Canadians already in crisis. We need both - but I’m glad to have at least one concern taken seriously.  


Secondly, Canada must play a significant role in an international movement to regulate new technologies. 

 

Specialists have been raising the flag about how unregulated AI can destabilize markets, institutions, and whole economies for many years - must people have waived off the risk. Today, the world is beginning to heed the warnings.  

 

I am personally passionate about cybersecurity. Mazon’s donor base leans older - the exact demographic targeted by scammers - and our team has felt the increase in "please update mycredit card information" calls from donors who have been compromised by scammers and hackers. For people of means and education, this is an annoyance - but for our neighbours with low financial literacy and no financial cushion, a single data breach can be a life-altering disruption, the beginning of a spiral into debt or homelessness.  

 

Unregulated AI has enabled bad-faith actors to work at unprecedented scale, and these harms cannot be contained by national borders. Canadians will not be safe from identity theft and hacking, and our food system will not be safe from disruptions, until an international treaty regulates the release and use of AI. This is to say nothing of the looming existential threat that super intelligent AI may pose to human life.  

 

Canada has already established ourselves as a leader among middle powers. Outside of my role at work, I’ve been personally volunteering for AI Governance and Safety, a Canadian organization protecting national interests (and humanity around the world) by calling on our government to become that international first mover, among other things. My support for AIGS is directly motivated by my desire to protect our Canadian and global food systems, and to protect Mazon and other small charities in a changing world.


As-is, there is already more hunger in our communities than we can bear. But there is still time to make changes that will protect our shared future.


Let's make good use of that time.


Blessings,


Izzy Waxman

Executive Director

 
 
bottom of page